Innovation: The Ticket to Growth in a Mature Market

By Tom Sullivan | August 10, 2005

One of the great joys of the coatings industry is that there is always an opportunity to build a better mousetrap

The featured speaker at RPM's management meeting last October was Ram Charan, an educator, management consultant and lead co-author of the book, Every Business Is a Growth Business. One of his central themes was that there is no such thing as a mature business. Reflecting on Mr. Charan's comments, I was thinking that for most of my 40-plus year career, the coatings industry has always been considered "mature," at least statistically.

RPM Leadership Then and Now
Founder Frank C. Sullivan in 1970 (left) and current president and CEO, Frank C. Sullivan (right).

Yet, in this "mature" industry, RPM International was able to grow sales for 55 out of its 56 years in business and to grow operating income in 54 of those 56 years. In both cases, our growth rates over the years have usually exceeded the averages in the key industry sectors in which we participate.

To me, one of the great joys of the coatings industry is that there is always an opportunity to "build a better mousetrap" or to meet an unfulfilled need that will allow a business to create or dominate a niche in a very non-homogenous industry.

RPM International was founded on just such a premise. My father, Frank C. Sullivan, started the original Republic Powdered Metals in 1947 around a unique asphaltic aluminum coating called Alumanation. Our Tremco unit still makes the product today and its sales continue to grow.

While the product was certainly important, the value system installed by my father was much more so. He always said, "Hire the best people you can find. Create an atmosphere to keep them. Then let them do their jobs."

After my father died in 1971, Jim Karman-my longtime business partner, close friend and retired RPM vice chairman-and I began making acquisitions using the same value system. We recognized that the coatings industry was consolidating, and we would have to be either a buyer or a seller.

Living History
Republic Powdered Metals, the precursor to RPM, was founded in 1947 on the strength of a roof covering product called Alumanation (left). Frank C. Sullivan referred to it as the "Coca-Cola of roof coatings." RPM's Tremco unit still manufactures Alumanation today.

Founding Philosophy Applied to Acquisitions
We opted to buy, and applied my father's value system to these acquisitions. Over the past 30 years, we have made nearly 100 acquisitions, with 58 occurring since 1991. Some have been the well-publicized deals such as Tremco, Rust-Oleum and DAP. But many more have been bolt-on product line acquisitions, such as Flecto and Epoxi-Tech, and stand alone independent niche businesses, such as Day-Glo and TCI Powdered Coatings.

Most of these acquisitions were family businesses, where the owners needed or wanted to sell for estate planning or other personal reasons. We offered them a chance to cash out, but to continue running and growing their businesses as part of RPM. Our goal is to be the best home for entrepreneurial companies in the markets we serve. I am extremely proud of the fact that our six senior operating managers all joined the company through acquisitions between 1984 and 1999. All of these individuals have seen substantial increases in their responsibilities since the acquisitions and their annual compensation reflects their heightened roles.

In our acquisition program, we try to do deals that have an exceptional chance of working out for both parties. Our criteria as we look at potential companies to join RPM include:

Complementary management goals and philosophy;
Participation in an industry or industry segment that we know;
Recognized leading brand in larger markets, a dominant player in a smaller niche market or a unique product line that can be quickly integrated into an existing RPM operating unit;
Gross margins at 40% or higher;
Strong management team that wants to grow their business further within RPM;
Cash flow positive and earnings accretive; and
A geographic focus on North America and Europe.

Innovation Brings Market Leadership
It is very difficult to become a major brand, to dominate a niche or to develop a unique product line without innovation. Over the years, RPM has been a heavy participant in all three of these situations, both through internal development and acquisition.

Two of our larger consumer businesses, Rust-Oleum and Zinsser, were both founded around the premise of an innovative product, but their legacy of innovation accelerated rapidly under RPM.

The original Rust-Oleum product, Stops Rust, was launched in 1921 by Admiral Robert Fergusson, following many years of research to develop a rust-preventative paint based on fish oil, but with no odor. When RPM acquired Rust-Oleum in 1994, it was the dominant brand of rust-preventative consumer coatings, yet offered only six colors of a single product line. Since then, Rust-Oleum has become the North American category leader in small package paints, offering decorative, general purpose, specialty purpose and rust-preventative coatings. In the process, it's more than tripled sales in nine years.

William Zinsser introduced bleached shellac to the U.S. market in 1849 and our Zinsser Co. unit continues to be the largest marketer of shellac-based products in the U.S., including the ubiquitous B-I-N primer sealer. During the ensuing century and a quarter prior to acquisition by RPM, Zinsser developed or acquired one-of-a-kind products to meet distinct consumer needs, including DIF wallpaper stripper, the first enzyme-based stripper; Bulls Eye 1-2-3, the first interior/exterior water-based primer sealer; and Shieldz wallcovering primer. Since being acquired by RPM in 1986, Zinsser has furthered its leadership in primer-sealers, wallcovering preparation and removal products and mildew-proof coatings and it, too, has seen sales increases that significantly outpace the industry.

Until fairly recently, RPM's acquisition process was driven by the corporate office. But we've realized that if we are going to reach our growth goals, our six major operating platforms need to conduct their own acquisition programs, applying RPM's proven principles. We are multiplying our acquisition resources.

Taking Care of Business
RPM's leadership style lets operating companies function with autonomy. Above are some of the RPM's key leaders. Left photo, (l-r): John J. McLaughlin, president, DAP Group; Michael D. Tellor, president, Rust-Oleum Group and Robert Senior, president, Zinsser Group. Right photo (l-r): Charles G. Pauli, president, RPM II Group; Jeffrey L. Korach, president, Tremco Group and David P. Reiff III, president, StonCor Group.

Time-ly Message
The company's first ad was placed in Time magazine in 1949. At left is a
Rust-Oleum advertisement from 1952.

Value of Innovation Not Limited to Sales
Innovation, of course, doesn't just apply to growing the top line. During the 2000 and 2001 fiscal years ended May 31, RPM went through painful restructuring and reorganization programs. For RPM, these were innovations in their own right, designed to restore earnings momentum, which had slowed in the late 1990s. Frank C. Sullivan, the company's chief executive officer and my son, was instrumental in both programs and led the reorganization process. RPM has posted nine consecutive quarters of improved operating earnings since the restructuring ended.

One key priority during my final year as CEO in fiscal 2002 was to restore the strength of our balance sheet, which had become highly leveraged following the acquisition of DAP in 1999 and essentially precluded us from the acquisition market. Through a successful follow-on public equity offering and a record $191 million in cash from operations in fiscal 2002, bolstered by another $161 million in cash from operations in fiscal 2003, we restored liquidity to the balance sheet. As a result, we have been back in the acquisition game in earnest for more than a year now.

Well-Positioned for Future Growth
In our final years as executive officers of RPM, Jim Karman and I sought to build a new management team capable of growing the business well beyond where it is today. We believe we have been successful.

In Frank Sullivan, we have a seasoned CEO who participated in approximately $1.7 billion of our growth since 1989. In his role, Frank brings both a strong financial discipline and adherence to the core values of RPM, including the founding philosophy concerning people and acquisitions. He's a supporter of RPM's dividend policy, which has generated 29 consecutive years of increases in the cash dividend. He also embraces the need to give back to our communities.

At the corporate office, Frank's eight-person management team averages 45 years of age and nine years of service to RPM. Operating leaders of RPM's six focused growth platforms have an average age of 56 and an average tenure of 28 years with RPM and predecessor entities. Operating management keeps RPM close to its customers, and is responsible for product development, marketing and manufacturing. This combination of energy and experience will continue to keep RPM at the forefront of innovation in the coatings industry.

Reflections on Innovation in Coatings
One of my great joys as CEO of RPM for more than three decades has been the opportunity to get to know so many exceptional people at the helms of companies in our industry, large and small. A large part of my personal focus during that time was on acquisitions, and for every deal we closed, we probably talked to ten other companies, giving me a pretty good perspective on the quality of people that make up this business and who have succeeded in generating growth in a "mature industry."

Tom Sullivan, chairman of RPM International Inc., is currently serving as chairman of the National Paint and Coatings Association.

Related Market & Technology:

  • China – A Maturing Economy

    China – A Maturing Economy

    Dan Watson , Contributing Writer||October 19, 2015
    Is China still an opportunity for investment?

  • Asia Pacific Report

    Asia Pacific Report

    August 17, 2015

  • Latin America Paint Outlook Mixed, But Growing

    Latin America Paint Outlook Mixed, But Growing

    Charles W. Thurston, Latin America Correspondent||June 17, 2015

  • Shifting Opportunities for Suppliers of Conductive Coatings

    Shifting Opportunities for Suppliers of Conductive Coatings

    Robert Nolan, NanoMarkets LLC||April 19, 2012
    A look at growth prospects in the conductive coatings segment.

  • The Resins Market

    The Resins Market

    Tim Wright, Editor||April 19, 2012
    Resins suppliers reported modest recovery in 2011 and are optimistic that these improvements will continue into 2012.

  • Auto OEM Coatings

    Auto OEM Coatings

    Tim Wright, Editor||March 19, 2012
    Lower costs, reduced air pollution and better performance are key drivers in automotive coatings and suppliers like BASF continue to offer new technologies and new products for the automotive industry.

  • Surfactants Update

    Surfactants Update

    Kerry Pianoforte, Associate Editor||March 19, 2012
    Surfactants manufacturers focus on environmental issues and developing “greener” technologies.

  • Pigments Market Update

    Pigments Market Update

    Kerry Pianoforte, Associate Editor||January 24, 2012
    Although still not back to pre-recession levels, the pigments market has continued to recover. Pigment companies are reporting a decrease in supply issues and an increase in demand for certain market segments, such as automotive coatings.

  • Growing Paint Additives Market

    Growing Paint Additives Market

    Tim Wright, Editor||January 24, 2012
    Environmental pressures and the growing shift toward water-based paint systems are fueling demand for paint and coating additives, providing tremendous growth potential for additives suppliers.

  • CHINACOAT2011 Was A Massive Success

    CHINACOAT2011 Was A Massive Success

    Tim Wright, Editor||January 24, 2012
    CHINACOAT2011 in Shanghai mirrored China's growing and dynamic coatings industry.

  • Architectural Coatings Market

    Architectural Coatings Market

    Tim Wright, Editor||January 24, 2012
    In high growth regions demand for architectural coatings continues to grow, but in the mature markets of North America and Western Europe difficult conditions remain.

  • The Adhesives and Sealants Market

    The Adhesives and Sealants Market

    Kerry Pianoforte, Associate Editor||November 10, 2011
    The adhesives and sealants market continues to be affected by the recession and raw material issues.

  • The Auto Refinish Market

    The Auto Refinish Market

    Kerry Pianoforte, Associate Editor||October 12, 2011
    The auto refinish market faces a slow down in demand in North America and Western Europe, but emerging markets offer growth opportunities.

  • White Roof Coatings Boost Solar Power

    White Roof Coatings Boost Solar Power

    Charles W. Thurston, Contributing Editor||September 14, 2011
    Most of the interest in white roofs comes from the heat reflection of the surface, which reduces energy consumption for cooling.

  • The Asia-Pacific Paint and Coatings Market

    The Asia-Pacific Paint and Coatings Market

    Scott Detiveaux, Allen Tsaur||August 15, 2011
    The Asia-Pacific region is an important and growing part of the global coatings marketplace. Unlike other regions of the world, the Asia-Pacific region has continued to grow, even in the face of the global recession.

  • In the Air With AkzoNobel Aerospace Coatings

    In the Air With AkzoNobel Aerospace Coatings

    A.S. Richardson||August 15, 2011
    Punching above its weight the aerospace coatings market is relatively small in terms of volume, but attracts a great deal of attention.

  • 2011 State of the Industry Review

    2011 State of the Industry Review

    July 13, 2011
    Executives reflect on the past year in coatings and look ahead to what the future might bring.

  • Marine Coatings

    Marine Coatings

    Kerry Pianoforte||May 9, 2011
    The marine coatings market experienced growth in 2010, driven primarily by strong newbuild activity in the shipping industry. However, raw material prices continue to challenge manufacturers in 2011.

  • Resins Market Report

    Resins Market Report

    Kerry Pianoforte||April 4, 2011
    Although 2010 continued to present difficulties for suppliers to the coatings industry, there were some indications of recovery. Resins suppliers interviewed by Coatings World reported some positive news.

  • On the spot with RED SPOT

    On the spot with RED SPOT

    Tim Wright||March 10, 2011
    A conversation about the latest market and technology trends in automotive coatings with the folks at Red Spot Paint and Varnish Co., Inc. Contributors include Janice Gould, Marketing Manager, Jeff Scheu, VP of Product Development/R&D and David White, VP of Sales and Marketing.

  • Toward a Clean Energy Future

    Toward a Clean Energy Future

    Tim Wright||March 10, 2011
    Coatings World caught up with former DuPont head Chad Holliday and discussed issues ranging from corporate environmental responsibility, sustainability, climate change and the American Energy Innovation Council.

  • The Surfactants Market

    The Surfactants Market

    Kerry Pianoforte||March 10, 2011
    Coatings World recently spoke with a number of surfactant suppliers to the coatings industry regarding the state of the market. Among the topics discussed were raw material costs, “green” chemistry and opportunities for growth.

  • Focus on China: Guangdong Carpoly

    Focus on China: Guangdong Carpoly

    Tim Wright||March 10, 2011
    Among the world’s top 40 paint producers, Guangdong Carpoly has ambitious growth plans for the future.

  • Adhesives and Sealants Market Update

    Kerry Pianoforte||November 1, 2010
    The adhesives and sealants market has rebounded somewhat this year, but all indications are that it will take several more years before it gains the levels seen before the recession.

  • Kansai Paint Expands in Middle East

    Kansai Paint Expands in Middle East

    Tim Wright||November 1, 2010
    As part of its expansion plans in the Middle East region, Japan’s leading coatings manufacturer recently inaugurated a new plant in Iran.