New Center for Green Schools Report on Indoor Air Quality in our Schools

The Center for Green Schools at the U.S. Green Building Council has released a new report detailing how school districts around the country have continued to manage air quality within their schools during the second year of the COVID-19 pandemic. The report, Managing Air Quality in the Pandemic: How K-12 Schools Addressed Air Quality in the Second Year of COVID-19, builds on an April 2021 report, “Preparation in the Pandemic: How Schools Implemented Air Quality Measures to Protect Occupants from COVID-19,” which was the first and only known national survey of on-the-ground implementation of indoor air quality (IAQ) improvements at schools during the COVID-19 pandemic. The new report highlights the urgent need to better support school districts with implementation of airborne infection control strategies to support mitigation of the immediate COVID-19 threat, as well as future pandemics, seasonal epidemics and to improve overall indoor air quality.

“Maintaining good indoor air quality is vital to support the health and wellness of students and faculty,” said Anisa Heming, director for the Center for Green Schools. “School districts recognize that proper ventilation is critical to curbing the spread of airborne diseases like COVID-19. However, more than two years into the pandemic, they still need support to find the right strategies and resources to make the necessary changes.”

The report shows that schools prioritized increasing outdoor air intake by whatever means were available to them and reflects on how the pandemic and schools’ responses to it have evolved. Importantly for national advocates, the survey responses indicate that school districts in different locales (urban versus non-urban) are seeking guidance from different types of sources.

Widespread education of school system administrators and staff is needed to ensure awareness of both the widely agreed-upon indoor air quality recommendations and the availability of federal COVID-19 relief funds for indoor air quality measures. To support schools, the White House’s updated COVID-19 strategies includes a focus on indoor air quality in schools, with the federal government investing millions to help schools improve ventilation as way to curb the spread of the virus and avoid shutdowns.

“Studies have shown a direct link between indoor air quality in schools and student performance and attendance,” said 2021-22 ASHRAE President Mick Schwedler, P.E., Fellow ASHRAE, LEED AP. “This study further underscores the importance of not only providing technical guidance for improving indoor air quality, but the need for practical implementation strategies. We trust that the findings in this report will lead to more knowledge sharing, expanded partnerships and greater investments to improve indoor air quality and decarbonize our schools.”

The Center for Green Schools report, which was co-authored with researchers from Lawrence Berkeley National Lab and developed with technical support from ASHRAE, illuminates strategies and challenges from school districts that serve over 2.6 million students in over 4,000 schools. Among major findings:

• The top challenge for schools in implementing many of the recommended indoor air quality (IAQ) measures was that buildings’ HVAC systems were not designed to implement the recommendations. Specific challenges were not found to be associated with any particular school district characteristics studied, such as demographics, locale or size.
• School district characteristics such as demographics, locale and size were not associated with the number of IAQ measures taken but were associated with the implementation of specific measures, such as increasing outdoor air through HVAC systems and assessing outdoor air delivery.
• American Rescue Plan (ARP) Elementary and Secondary School Emergency Relief (ESSER) funding has been used to support the implementation of IAQ measures more than funding from operating or capital budgets. Just over half of school districts reported that they felt they had access to funding to support additional IAQ-related building improvements.
• Non-urban districts were more likely to lean on state and local guidance, and urban districts were more likely to use federal-level guidance and guidance from national organizations like ASHRAE.
• Over a quarter of districts responded that there were no new plans to implement additional ventilation, filtration or other building changes in schools.

The Center for Green Schools’ work to develop and release this report was made possible through generous support from Trane® – by Trane Technologies.

“Even with effective strategies and funding available, school systems are still challenged to implement recommended indoor air quality measures,” said Donny Simmons, president, Commercial HVAC Americas, Trane Technologies. “Among the many barriers illustrated in the report is that indoor air quality is not one-size-fits-all; school systems need more support to develop tailored solutions that address industry best practices and the specific needs and desired outcomes for the school. As a longstanding partner in education, we are proud to support this important work to create healthier, more comfortable and sustainable learning environments for students and staff, setting schools and communities up for lasting success.”

The report was compiled from a national survey of public school districts during October-December 2021 to assess the implementation of a range of ventilation, filtration, disinfection and air quality monitoring strategies; and was followed by focus group discussions with participants. View the full report.