• Login
    • Join
  • FOLLOW:
  • Subscribe Free
    • Magazine
    • eNewsletter
    Checkout
    • Magazine
    • News
    • Research
    • Markets & Technologies
    • Raw Materials
    • Top Companies
    • Directories
    • Jobs
    • Events
    • Microsites
    • More
  • Magazine
  • News
  • Research
  • Markets & Technologies
  • Raw Materials
  • Top Companies
  • Directories
  • Jobs
  • Events
  • Microsites
  • Current / Back Issues
    Features
    Business Corner
    Editorial
    Digital Edition
    eNewsletter Archive
    Our Team
    Editorial Guidelines
    Subscribe Now
    Advertise Now
    World Reports
    eBook
    Top Features
    Additives Update

    Pigment Supplier Directory

    Interior Architectural Coatings

    Biocides Update

    Powder Coatings Market
    Breaking News
    Online Exclusives
    Distributor News
    Financial News
    Paint & Coatings Manufacturer News
    People In the News
    Price Increases
    Product News
    Video Bites
    Raw Materials & Equipment
    Suppliers News
    Live From Shows
    Top News
    Mankiewicz Announces Leadership Change in Aviation Division

    AkzoNobel Attains Top Employer Status

    PPG Reports Q4, Full-year 2020 Financial Results

    BASF Begins Implementing Ralignment of Global Business Services Unit

    Nouryon Appoints Curtis Espeland to Board of Directors
    Top Companies report
    Market Research
    White Papers / Tech Papers
    Technical Papers
    Product Spec Sheets
    World Reports
    Adhesives and Sealants
    Aerospace Coatings
    Architectural Coatings
    Automotive Coatings
    Automotive Refinish
    Business Operation
    Color Trends & Forecast
    Construction Chemicals
    Corrosion Control
    Industrial Coatings
    Laboratory Equipment
    Marine Coatings
    Market Trends & Forecast
    Powder Coatings
    Production Equipment
    Radcure Coatings
    Special Purpose Coatings
    Wood Coatings
    "Green" Coatings

    Mankiewicz Announces Leadership Change in Aviation Division

    AMETEK Brookfield Opens Media Room at US HQ

    AkzoNobel Supplying Powder Coatings for Landmark Water Pipeline in China

    IGL Coatings Launches Graphene Reinforced Dual System Ceramic Coating

    Miller Paint Declares Simple Serenity its 2021 Color of the Year
    Additives
    Binders
    Pigments
    Solvents

    Active Minerals Announces Shipping Container Surcharge

    Huntsman Finalizes Acquisition of Gabriel Performance Products

    LANXESS Acquires Biocides Specialist INTACE

    dar-tech, inc. Becomes U.S. Midwestern Distributor for ZS Interpolymer

    OQ Chemicals Announces Carboxylic Acids Price Increase
    Buyers Guide
    Company Capabilities
    Distributor Guide
    Add New Company
    International Buyers Guide Companies
    Eagle Specialty Products

    Active Minerals

    Shepherd Color Company, The

    Pilot Chemical Company

    Keim Additec Surface USA LLC
    Industry Events
    Webinars
    Live From Show Event
    Top Events
    The Waterborne Symposium (2021)

    Cleveland Coatings Society Zoom Meeting

    Surface Finishing Mexico 2021

    Cleveland Coatings Society Zoom Meeting

    Cleveland Coatings Society Zoom Meeting
    Companies
    White Papers/Tech Papers
    Product Spec Sheets
    Equipment
    Literature/Brochures
    Videos
    International Buyers Guide Companies
    Siltech Corporation

    Pilot Chemical Company

    Eagle Specialty Products

    Shepherd Color Company, The

    Keim Additec Surface USA LLC
    • Magazine
      • Current / Back Issues
      • Features
      • Editorial
      • Business Corner
      • Digital Edition
      • eNewsletter Archive
      • Editorial Guidelines
      • Subscribe Now
      • Advertise Now
    • Breaking News
    • Directories
      • Buyers Guide
      • Distributor Guide
      • Corporate Capabilities
      • Trade Associations
      • Add Your Company
    • Markets & Technologies
      • Adhesives and Sealants
      • Aerospace Coatings
      • Architectural Coatings
      • Automotive Coatings
      • Automotive Refinish
      • Business Operation
      • Color Trends & Forecast
      • Construction Chemicals
      • Corrosion Control
      • Industrial Coatings
      • Laboratory Equipment
      • Marine Coatings
      • Market Trends & Forecast
      • Powder Coatings
      • Production Equipment
      • Radcure Coatings
      • Special Purpose Coatings
      • Wood Coatings
      • "Green" Coatings
    • Raw Materials
      • Additives
      • Binders
      • Pigments
      • Solvents
    • World Reports
      • Africa Report
      • China Report
      • India/Asia Pacific Report
      • Europe Report
      • Latin America Report
      • Market Research
      • Russian Report
    • Top Companies
    • Online Exclusives
    • Slideshows
    • Experts Opinions
    • Blog
    • eBook
    • Infographics
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Whitepapers
    • Jobs
    • Microsites
      • Companies
      • White Papers/Tech Papers
      • Product Spec Sheets
      • Equipment
      • Literature/Brochures
      • Videos
    • Events
      • Industry Events
      • Live From Show Event
      • Webinars
    • About Us
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use
    IPaint

    Death, Taxes, Trade Secrets and Other Certainties

    ...

    Related CONTENT
    • GreenMantra Technologies Introduces New Ceranovus Polypropylene Waxes
    • Emerald Kalama Chemical Appoints Dowd and Guild Inc. Distributor in the Western U.S. for K-Flex
    • AFX Completes New U.S. Production Line: Brings The Accordion Paint Baffle Home
    • Green Biologics Awarded BDC’s Commercialization Achievement Award
    • Intumescent Coatings Market to be Valued at $1 Billion by 2024
    Steve McDaniel and Jon Hurt , Technology Litigators06.17.15
    Since many of you like to take the extension to file taxes these days (we did), and you have a little time to prepare for next April, now is a good time as any to apply the “early bird gets the worm” strategy should any of the following issues ring a warning bell in the back of your mind.  Sure, we are not accountants or tax attorneys, so don’t take anything we say here as tax advice.  That being said, trade secrets can have tax consequences that you may want to discuss with your honest-to-Pete tax advisor. 

    Are trade secrets taxable property?  Short answer, yes.  What, did you think the IRS is going to miss a chance to bleed you?  But like most things tax related, the specifics are somewhat buried in the forest of dead trees that make up the current tax code.  Under 26 U.S. Code § 170 “Charitable, etc., contributions and gifts” various intellectual properties including trade secrets are recognized as tax related assets:  “(e) Certain contributions of ordinary income and capital gain property … (1) General rule … The amount of any charitable contribution of property otherwise taken into account under this section shall be reduced by the sum of - … (A) the amount of gain which would not have been long-term capital gain (determined without regard to section 1221(b)(3)) if the property contributed had been sold by the taxpayer at its fair market value (determined at the time of the contribution), and (B) in the case of a charitable contribution - … (iii) of any patent, copyright (other than a copyright described in section 1221(a)(3) or 1231(b)(1)C)), trademark, trade name, trade secret, know-how, software (other than software described in section 197(e)(3)A((ii)), or similar property, or applications or registrations of such property, or … the amount of gain which would have been long-term capital gain if the property contributed had been sold by the taxpayer at its fair market value (determined at the time of such contribution).”  Whew!  And, we thought patent law was indecipherable! 

    From the convoluted verbosity above, you can see why you are going to need a joint sit down with your tax advisor and your attorney to figure out the best joint tax and legal positioning to take on your trade secrets and other intellectual property.  But it seems that you can get some type of tax benefit for giving trade secrets, “know how” and other IP assets away as a charitable contribution.  Big whoop.  Most people want to make money from their trade secrets rather than give them away.  And honestly, can anyone think of a charity that would want or use a trade secret from the paint and coatings industry? If you do, please contact us and we will be sure that our not-for-profit entity has been set up to receive them! 

    Another issue that arises is the difference between a trade secret and know-how.  The IRS has generally long viewed know-how as existing based on a trade secret status, as having or including a secret process or formula that is not necessarily patentable, and that it can be duplicated by an employee that leaves the company.  Know-how in this view falls under the trade secret umbrella and the proceeds from the sale of know-how can be taxed as a capital gain.  In regards to trade secrets, any benefit of the capital gains rate may be lost if the IRS rules that the confidential information did not classify as a trade secret (i.e., property), such as not being protected by adequate secrecy (hint, hint . . . . see previous iPaint articles).  However, the subject of know-how has produced differing opinions between courts and the IRS in various cases.  In some court rulings non-secret information (e.g., manuals, easily reversed engineered processes) was viewed as know-how and still taxable as property in the sale of a business.  The tax issues with trade secrets and know-how gets even more complicated when your business is international, another topic to raise during the sit-down with your advisors.

    Given the treatment of trade secrets and other IP as property, there may be several ways to categorize R&D costs of their development for reducing your tax bill.  The sit-down topics include the research and development (R&D) deduction or the R&D tax credit (if it is currently renewed – the tax code is always changing).  For example, based on the Snow v. Commissioner U.S. Supreme Court ruling, a partnership investor may be able to deduct the expenses related to developing a product even though the product has not been offered for sale or sold.  And if you wind up meeting all the various criteria for both the R&D deduction and the R&D tax credit, the formula can become complicated as you need to subtract one from the other in determining the final deduction.  Keep good records, and hope your tax advisor’s computer is up to the task.

    If you write a check and buy (e.g., lump sum payment, installment fees, renewal fees) intellectual property for your business, you also may be able to amortize over 15 years the cost of the purchase per 26 U.S. Code § 197.  The qualifying intangible property under § 197(d)(1)(C)(iii)  includes “any patent, copyright, formula, process, design, pattern, know-how, format or other similar item,”  So “trade secret” is not named, but “know-how” and “other similar items” are named.  Another topic for discussion at the sit-down.  Intangible property that the taxpayer creates rather than purchases may also be eligible under § 197(c)(2) if it was created “in connection with a transaction (or series of related transactions) involving the acquisition of assets constituting a trade or business or substantial portion thereof.”  Should § 197 not be applicable, then have your advisor mull over the potential for counting the cost under R&D expenses (§ 174), depreciation (§ 167), or even ordinary business expenses (§ 162). 

    Now suppose you sell a trade secret or other intellectual property.  The way you “sell” it can have a big impact on your tax bill, specifically whether it qualifies as ordinary income vs. a capital gain.  The considerations are whether you only partly transfer (i.e., license) the property vs. exchange all substantial rights of the property; and whether the property qualifies as the provision of services or a non-capital asset vs. a capital asset (e.g., one held for more than one year).  As you can guess, meeting the two later categories will get you into the capital gain bracket, if that is desirable to you.  In Pickren v. United States 378 F.2d 595 (5th Cir. 1967) the transfer of rights and interest of secret formula to liquid wax products and trade names were viewed by the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals as warranting the application of the transfer of patent rights, which under current 26 U.S. Code § 1235 would constitute a sale of a capital asset if all substantial rights were transferred.  However, royalty payments under a licensing agreement for the formula and trade names was viewed as ordinary income.  The IRS has generally categorized this “secret formula” type of information as “know-how.” 

    Finally, how about the situation where your trade secret was misappropriated, and you win damages and/or settle the case?  Well, in Freda v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 2011 WL 3802707 (August 26, 2011, 7th Cir. 2011) (Freda), the way the tax rate on $15.3 million in damage payments was decided really gives notice to all litigators.  The circumstances involved were C&F Packing Co., Inc. (C&F) freezing cooked sausages for Pizza Hut, Inc. (Pizza Hut), and providing confidential disclosure of the trade secret for the freezing process to Pizza Hut due to quality control concerns.  Pizza Hut then allegedly disclosed C&F’s trade secret to other sausage producers that partly took over production, at lower cost of course.  After many legal battles over a decade, C&F won $10.9 million in damages for claims of “lost profits, lost opportunities, operating costs, and expenditures.”  That award was reported as about $8 million in long-term gain and the rest as ordinary income.  The IRS was OK with that filing.  A related court case claiming trade secret misappropriation was settled for $15.3 million, which after expenses, legal fees, and a payment to a former shareholder, C&F reported about $6 million in cash as a long term capital gain.  However, the IRS took the view that the settlement was ordinary income, the result being that $700,000+ in taxes were owed by C&F’s shareholders.  The problem for C&F in the trade secret misappropriation case was the type of claim made.  The Court indicated that if C&F sought remedy for replacement of capital destroyed or injured, then the payment would have been a return of capital “and not taxable,” rather than ordinary income for payment of lost royalties and profits.  Ouch.  Goes to show that getting the whole team together to play war games is really key to long-term success.

    So, repeating the disclaimer here that your authors have any tax expertise whatsoever, do yourself a favor.  Know enough to know how little you know (the mark of the truly educated).  And, beware of tax advice regarding taxable consequences of trade secret development, ownership, protection, licensing and sale.  Such advisers will need to be of a special sort, and have demonstrable expertise in the area. There are certainties in life – death, taxes.  Don’t smoke, our best advice (as non-doctors), for the former.  Pay what you owe, but don’t forget to consider the tax consequences of your trade secrets, our best advice (as non-tax specialists), for the latter. 
    Related Searches
    • leed
    Suggested For You
    GreenMantra Technologies Introduces New Ceranovus Polypropylene Waxes GreenMantra Technologies Introduces New Ceranovus Polypropylene Waxes
    Emerald Kalama Chemical Appoints Dowd and Guild Inc. Distributor in the Western U.S. for K-Flex Emerald Kalama Chemical Appoints Dowd and Guild Inc. Distributor in the Western U.S. for K-Flex
    AFX Completes New U.S. Production Line: Brings The Accordion Paint Baffle Home AFX Completes New U.S. Production Line: Brings The Accordion Paint Baffle Home
    Green Biologics Awarded BDC’s Commercialization Achievement Award Green Biologics Awarded BDC’s Commercialization Achievement Award
    Intumescent Coatings Market to be Valued at $1 Billion by 2024 Intumescent Coatings Market to be Valued at $1 Billion by 2024
    Acquisitive Opportunity Investigation: What Are The Conditioned Expectations? Acquisitive Opportunity Investigation: What Are The Conditioned Expectations?
    RCMA Reflective Roof Rebates Database Now Available to the Public RCMA Reflective Roof Rebates Database Now Available to the Public
    IHS: Westlake Chemical Move to Carve Out its Ethylene Assets, Leveraging Tax Advantages IHS: Westlake Chemical Move to Carve Out its Ethylene Assets, Leveraging Tax Advantages
    Who Let the State Legislatures Out? Who Let the State Legislatures Out?
    Tying and Bundling - Nice For Your Holiday Giving, Not so Much When You’re Licensing Your IP Tying and Bundling - Nice For Your Holiday Giving, Not so Much When You’re Licensing Your IP
    Promoting Growth: PPG and the Chemical Industry Need Help that Lawmakers Can Provide Promoting Growth: PPG and the Chemical Industry Need Help that Lawmakers Can Provide
    Many Secrets Disclosed Unless Smartly Done! Many Secrets Disclosed Unless Smartly Done!
    Roof Coating Professionals and Members of Congress Discuss Key Industry Issues Roof Coating Professionals and Members of Congress Discuss Key Industry Issues
    Chromaflo Technologies Hires Tax and Compliance Manager Chromaflo Technologies Hires Tax and Compliance Manager
    The Hot Potato – Handling Someone Else’s Trade Secret The Hot Potato – Handling Someone Else’s Trade Secret

    Related IPaint

    • Who Let the State Legislatures Out?

      ...
      Steve McDaniel & Jon Hurt 12.18.15

    • Tying and Bundling - Nice For Your Holiday Giving, Not so Much When You’re Licensing Your IP

      ...
      Steve McDaniel, Technology Litigators 11.13.15

    • Additives

      Many Secrets Disclosed Unless Smartly Done!

      ...
      Steve McDaniel, Technology Litigators 09.21.15


    • The Hot Potato – Handling Someone Else’s Trade Secret

      ...
      Steve McDaniel and Jon Hurt , Technology Litigators 07.20.15

    • Business Operation

      Several Shades of Grey: Who Owns The Trade Secret - The Creator or the Employer?

      ...
      Steve McDaniel and Jon Hurt, Technology Litigators 04.17.15

    • The Secret about Trade Secrets (In Europe)

      ...
      Steve McDaniel and Jon Hurt, Technology Litigators 03.25.15


    • Business Operation

      Going to Court: Hard Spots and Rocks!

      ...
      by Steve McDaniel and Jon Hurt , Technology Litigators 02.23.15

    • Business Operation

      What the FOIA! Freedom of Information Act vs. Secrecy of Your Trade Secrets

      ...
      Steve McDaniel and Jon Hurt, Contributing Writers 12.15.14

    • International Trade Commission – Your "Hometown Sheriff" in the Unfair Foreign Competition Shootout

      ...
      Steve McDaniel and John Hurt, Contributing Editors 10.20.14


    • Trusting Your Trade Secrets to "Lucky" the Dragon

      ...
      Steve McDaniel, JD, PhD, Contributing Editor 09.23.14

    • Pigments

      Welcome Back, For the New Season of the Made-for-CW Drama, iPaint

      ...
      Steve McDaniel, JD PhD, Contributing Editor 07.07.14

    • All Good things...Must Come to an End...Unless They're Really Good, Like You Know, Chocolate

      The year in review.
      Steve McDaniel, Beth McDaniel and Jn Hurt, Technology Litigators 12.11.13


    • Hacked Off!

      Whatever you do, take measures to lock up your sensitive information.
      Steve McDaniel, JD, PhD, Technology Litigators 10.23.13

    • Covering the IP Bases with Different Types of Patent Claims

      ...
      John D. Hurt and Steve McDaniel, Technology LItigators 08.13.13

    • Going back to College for a Trade Secrets Graduate Degree

      Don't take IP from the University, give it to them
      Steve McDaniel, Technology Litigators 06.06.13

    Trending
    • BASF Begins Implementing Ralignment Of Global Business Services Unit
    • New Strategy Sets Hempel On Path To Leadership Positions
    • Benjamin Moore Bringing Products To Wider Audience With UK Acquisition
    • AkzoNobel Attains Top Employer Status
    Breaking News
    • Mankiewicz Announces Leadership Change in Aviation Division
    • AkzoNobel Attains Top Employer Status
    • PPG Reports Q4, Full-year 2020 Financial Results
    • BASF Begins Implementing Ralignment of Global Business Services Unit
    • Nouryon Appoints Curtis Espeland to Board of Directors
    View Breaking News >
    CURRENT ISSUE

    January 2021

    • Additives Update
    • Pigment Supplier Directory
    • Interior Architectural Coatings
    • View More >

    Cookies help us to provide you with an excellent service. By using our website, you declare yourself in agreement with our use of cookies.
    You can obtain detailed information about the use of cookies on our website by clicking on "More information”.

    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms And Conditions
    • Contact Us

    follow us

    Subscribe
    Nutraceuticals World

    Latest Breaking News From Nutraceuticals World

    Oleic Acid Possibly Implicated in MS Pathology
    NIH Study Compares Low-Fat, Plant-Based to Low-Carb, Animal-Based Diet
    Gadot Positions Mineral Line for Vegan Market
    Coatings World

    Latest Breaking News From Coatings World

    APV Engineered Coatings Reflects on 2020
    LINE-X Launches Dealer Program with International Truck
    Mankiewicz Announces Leadership Change in Aviation Division
    Medical Product Outsourcing

    Latest Breaking News From Medical Product Outsourcing

    Alleviant's Transcatheter Tech Obtains Breakthrough Status
    Signia Appoints New President
    At-Home COVID-19 Test Kits Boosts Disease Monitoring Capabilities
    Contract Pharma

    Latest Breaking News From Contract Pharma

    Civica to Build an Essential Medicines Manufacturing Facility in Virginia
    Humanigen, Emergent Enter Covid-19 Partnership
    Samsung Bioepis Opens New Headquarters
    Beauty Packaging

    Latest Breaking News From Beauty Packaging

    e.l.f. Cosmetics Unveils Mint Melt Collection
    Estée Lauder Companies Updates Supply Chain Leadership
    Weekly Recap: JLo Beauty Launches, Unilever Partners with Alibaba, Estée Lauder Appoints SVP & More
    Happi

    Latest Breaking News From Happi

    Degree Launches Bath and Shower Range
    Estée Lauder Companies Updates Supply Chain Leadership
    Clorox Reaches Renewable Electricity Marker
    Ink World

    Latest Breaking News From Ink World

    Paragon Expands Direct Mail Capabilities with Ricoh Pro VC70000
    BOBST Demonstrates Future of Flexible Packaging Production at Virtual Open House
    Morancé Soudure France Adds Comexi F2 MC 10-color Flexo Press
    Label & Narrow Web

    Latest Breaking News From Label & Narrow Web

    VPF launches deep-freeze adhesive
    ProMach strengthens flexible packaging business
    Gallus planning virtual event for March
    Nonwovens Industry

    Latest Breaking News From Nonwovens Industry

    Kimberly-Clark Releases Q4, Full Year Results
    Freudenberg to Establish Apparel Interlining Competence Centers
    Minet Adds Spunlace Line in Romania
    Orthopedic Design & Technology

    Latest Breaking News From Orthopedic Design & Technology

    First Patient Implanted With NEXXT MATRIXX SA Cervical Turn-Lock System
    Cretex Companies CEO Steps Down
    Conformis Enters Development & Supply Agreement with SITES Medical
    Printed Electronics Now

    Latest Breaking News From Printed Electronics Now

    First Solar Signs Definitive Agreement to Sell US Development Platform to Leeward
    Osram in Top 25 of World’s 100 Most Sustainable Companies
    Graphene Flagship Study Predicts Increased Market Penetration by 2025

    Copyright © 2021 Rodman Media. All rights reserved. Use of this constitutes acceptance of our privacy policy The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Rodman Media.

    AD BLOCKER DETECTED

    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
    Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.


    FREE SUBSCRIPTION Already a subscriber? Login